Showing posts with label Ravich Law Firm. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ravich Law Firm. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

2014: One Hundred Years of Commercial Air Travel Marked


Happy New Year and Blue Skies in 2014!

Now, at a time when resolutions are made, is also a good time to reflect on something most Americans, and many people around the world, in fact, take for granted.

What's that? Well, the very first day of this new year begins with a very important celebration and anniversary, the first commercial (for hire) airplane flight.

It happened in Florida, whatever the dispute among North Carolina, Ohio, and Connecticut regarding the title of "first to fly."



Reports the Wall Street Journal online:
On Jan. 1, 1914, a wood-and-muslin Benoist XIV flying boat, powered by a noisy, six-cylinder, 75-horsepower engine, took off from St. Petersburg, Fla., with its pilot and one passenger sitting on a small wooden bench, exposed to the elements. The rickety seaplane traveled 18 miles as the crow flies, landing in the Hillsboro River off Tampa, a 23-minute journey at speeds up to 60 miles an hour. Normally such a trip would take two hours on a steam ship across Tampa Bay.

The flight carried a former St. Petersburg mayor who paid $400—about $9,323 in current dollars—for the thrill. It was repeated many times over the next four months, during the short life of the St. Petersburg-Tampa Airboat Line. Historians estimate that more than 1,200 passengers made the trip without mishap, paying $5 one-way, or $116.53 today.
As can be imagined, apart from laws protecting property or holding people responsible for their negligence or intentional acts, there were few laws in 1914 concerning aviation specifically. Over the next ten years, however, there was substantial legal activity at the local, state, national, and international levels as aviation went from "ultrahazardous activity" to a more progressive legal regime that accepted aviation technology as routine without diminishing individual rights where accidents might occur.

Today, 100 years later, we are at a similar point with respect to space commerce.

Saturday, November 23, 2013

Update to Airport Premises Liability Law in Florida


Ravich Law Firm, P.A. is pleased to release its 2014 Florida Aviation and Space Law Report.

Among the cases reported there is Kenz v. Miami-Dade County, an interesting lawsuit involving the burden of proof in airport slip and fall cases.

After slipping on liquid and falling at Miami International Airport, a pedestrian filed suit against Miami-Dade County, alleging permanent injuries.  At the time suit was filed, Fla. Stat. § 768.0710 (2002) was in effect, providing that in a negligence action involving a transitory foreign substance in a business establishment, “[a]ctual or constructive notice of the transitory foreign object or substance is not a required element of proof to this claim.” 

After suit was filed, but before trial commenced, Fla. Stat. § 768.0755 (2010) took effect and superseded Fla. Stat. § 768.0710, effectively returning Florida law to an earlier status, and providing that a person who slips and falls on a transitory foreign substance in a business establishment “must prove that the business establishment had actual or constructive knowledge of the dangerous condition and should have taken action to remedy it.”  Miami-Dade County subsequently filed a motion seeking a determination that § 768.0755 was applicable to the case and that the statute should apply retroactively because it was procedural in nature, rather than substantive. 

Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Spencer Eig entered summary judgment adverse to the plaintiff given the absence of any proof the county had actual or constructive notice of any dangerous condition.  Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal affirmed given the procedural nature of issues relating to a party’s burden of proof.

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Rule Changes in the Air


The Federal Aviation Administration ("FAA") has determined that airlines can safely expand passenger use of Portable Electronic Devices (PEDs) during all phases of flight, and is immediately providing the airlines with guidance. "Expanded use will not happen overnight," says the FAA.  "The process will vary among airlines, but the agency expects airlines to allow passengers to safely use their devices in airplane mode, gate-to-gate, by the end of 2013."


Meanwhile, as part part of its "ongoing efforts to enhance safety and put the best qualified and trained pilots in the flight decks of U.S. airplanes," the FAA also issued a final rule that will significantly advance the way commercial air carrier pilots are trained. 

In addition, FAA Administrator Michael Huerta is inviting the nation’s commercial aviation safety leaders to Washington, D.C. on November 21, to discuss additional voluntary steps that can be taken to further boost safety during airline operations, including pilot training.

“Today’s rule is a significant advancement for aviation safety and U.S. pilot training,” said U.S. Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx. “One of my first meetings as Transportation Secretary was with the Colgan Flight 3407 families, and today, I am proud to announce that with their help, the FAA has now added improved pilot training to its many other efforts to strengthen aviation safety.”

The final rule stems in part from the tragic crash of Colgan Air 3407 in February 2009, and addresses a Congressional mandate in the Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010 to ensure enhanced pilot training. The rule is one of several rulemakings required by the Act, including the requirements to prevent pilot fatigue that were finalized in December 2011, and the increased qualification requirements for first officers who fly U.S. passenger and cargo planes that were issued in July 2013.


The final rule requires:
  • ground and flight training that enables pilots to prevent and recover from aircraft stalls and upsets. These new training standards will impact future simulator standards as well;
  • air carriers to use data to track remedial training for pilots with performance deficiencies, such as failing a proficiency check or unsatisfactory performance during flight training;
  • training for more effective pilot monitoring;
  • enhanced runway safety procedures; and
  • expanded crosswind training, including training for wind gusts.
"This pivotal rule will give our nation’s pilots the most advanced training available,” said FAA Administrator Michael Huerta. “While the rule marks a major step toward addressing the greatest known risk areas in pilot training, I’m also calling on the commercial aviation industry to continue to move forward with voluntary initiatives to make air carrier training programs as robust as possible.”  
The FAA is focusing on pilot training for events that, although rare, are often catastrophic. Focusing on these events will provide the greatest safety benefit to the flying public. The recent rule to boost pilot qualifications for first officers has raised the baseline knowledge and skill set of pilots entering air carrier operations. Many air carriers have also voluntarily begun developing safety management systems (SMS), which will help air carriers identify and mitigate risks unique to their own operating environments.
The FAA proposed to revise the training rules for pilots in 2009, one month prior to the Colgan Flight 3407 accident. The FAA issued a supplemental proposal on May 20, 2011, to address many of the NTSB’s recommendations resulting from the accident, and incorporate congressional mandates for stick pusher, stall recovery and remedial training. A stick pusher is a safety system that applies downward elevator pressure to prevent an airplane from exceeding a predetermined angle of attack in order to avoid, identify, or assist in the recovery of a stall.

On Aug. 6, 2012, the FAA issued Advisory Circular (AC) Stall and Stick Pusher Training to provide best practices and guidance for training, testing, and checking for pilots to ensure correct and consistent responses to unexpected stall events and stick pusher activations.

Air carriers will have five years to comply with the rule’s new pilot training provisions, which will allow time for the necessary software updates to be made in flight simulation technology. The cost of the rule to the aviation industry is estimated to be $274.1 to $353.7 million. The estimated benefit is nearly double the cost at $689.2 million. 

The final rule is available here.

Wednesday, August 21, 2013



On August 13, 2013, the United States Department of Justice  and attorneys general from six states, including Florida,and the District of Columbia filed a lawsuit challenging the $11 billion merger of American Airlines and US Airways, saying the combination would lead to higher prices and less service for consumers. 

 A formatted copy of the complaint appears below. 

Interestingly, these cases have proven very difficult for the government to establish. In the late 1990s, for example, the Department of Justice was not successful in prosecuting American Airlines (via its parent AMR) for "predatory pricing." Antitrust enforcement is a highly complicated area of the law. The goal of such litigation is to make sure that consumers are not worse off in the long run as a result of market behavior that actually reduces competition.  While that sounds easy and good, marshaling the facts and evidence and expert resources to prove that free market impulses should be stopped requires tremendous legal resources.

While globally important, this lawsuit is particularly important to South Florida and Miami residents who have already suffered the demised of Eastern Air Lines and Pan Am in years past.

Department of Justice Complaint (Re USAir -American merger) by Timothy M. Ravich, Esq.

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Keeping up with the Times: Aircraft Certification Rules Updated


The FAA Modernization and Reform Act of 2012 requires the Federal Aviation Administration ("FAA"), in consultation with the aviation industry, to conduct an assessment of the aircraft certification and approval process.

In response to this mandate, the FAA announced it is "streamlining aircraft certification and approval processes to keep pace with technological advancements in aviation products and to help the United States maintain global competitiveness. The plan responds to recommendations in the May 2012 Aircraft Certification Process Review and Reform Aviation Rulemaking Committee report to enhance the efficiency of getting new products to market while improving safety." Says the FAA:
Many initiatives are already complete or underway. For example, the FAA is preparing to update the Part 23 regulations that cover design and safety standards for small, general aviation aircraft. The goal is to increase safety, decrease costs, and increase the installation of safety equipment for general aviation. The FAA also published for public comment a new process for initiating and managing FAA resources assigned to projects; it promotes more predictable planning for the applicant. And the FAA has issued an update to the Organization Delegation Authorization Order (8110.4D) and established an Aviation Rulemaking Committee to consider updates for certification procedures and safety management systems in Part 21.
As aircraft operators review their compliance strategy, the plan, which will be updated every six months, can be evaluated here. 

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Ground Matters

News is now filtering in about a recent commercial airline accident apparently owing to a front landing gear malfunction.


View more videos at: http://nbcnewyork.com.

There have been several accidents or incidents at New York's LaGuardia Airport, including this one. There was Flight 5050, where a 737 went off a runway


And, of course, there was Captain "Sully" Sullenberger and the "Miracle on the Hudson"


All of these events, together with the recent tragedy in San Francisco, highlights how important the aviation environment and airports are even beyond safety in the national airspace.  The Federal Aviation Administration ("FAA") strictly regulates most airport operations.  Ground operations can make aviation incidents worse, or as apparently happened in this case, well, not as bad.  

From a legal perspective, aviation accidents involve many more actors than just the airplane and its crew.  Air traffic control, ground operators, manufacturers, and many other parties are involved (thought not necessarily responsible or liable) both in accident litigation - and aviation safety.